Omar, Have Some Shame!

Columnist M S Shanker, Orange News 9

National Conference cannot demand constitutional trust while refusing to shed its political obsession with pre-2019 Kashmir

Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah wants the Centre to stop keeping his government in the dark over the restoration of statehood. But before lecturing New Delhi on political commitments, shouldn’t he first answer some uncomfortable questions about his family’s political legacy and the National Conference’s contradictory positions on Jammu and Kashmir’s relationship with Bharat?

There is something profoundly incongruous about a political dynasty repeatedly demanding trust from the Centre while continuing to defend the very constitutional arrangement that Parliament dismantled in August 2019. Omar and his father, Farooq Abdullah, have consistently opposed the abrogation of Articles 370 and 35A. The National Conference has never concealed its desire to restore the erstwhile special status, and its 2000 resolution seeking pre-1953 autonomy remains an unmistakable illustration of its political thinking.

What exactly is the National Conference seeking? Statehood within the Bharatiya constitutional framework, or a return to the political dispensation that allowed Jammu and Kashmir to function under a separate Constitution and its own flag? The distinction is fundamental, and the people of Bharat deserve an unequivocal answer.

The Abdullah family cannot conveniently rewrite its political history every time it finds itself in power. Farooq Abdullah’s 2014 warning that abrogating Article 370 would lead to massive unrest and his subsequent campaign for its restoration are matters of public record. Omar himself, after the August 2019 decision, declared that his party had not abandoned its demand for Article 370. These were not isolated political utterances. They reflected a consistent party position.

More troubling is the National Conference leadership’s approach to Pakistan. Farooq Abdullah’s repeated advocacy of dialogue with Islamabad, even amid Pakistan-sponsored terrorism, has raised legitimate questions about the party’s priorities. His controversial 2020 remarks about China and Article 370 triggered a political storm, forcing the party to issue a clarification. Disagreement with the Centre is a democratic right; but political leaders in a border state cannot afford ambiguity when confronting a neighbouring country that has repeatedly sponsored terrorism against Bharat.

Will Pakistan decide J&K statehood, asks CM Omar | India News - The Times  of India

Omar must understand that patriotism cannot be a convenient political costume, worn during one phase of a political career and discarded during another. His own tenure in the Atal Bihari Vajpayee government saw him adopt a distinctly different public posture towards Pakistan. Those days of strong rhetoric against the neighbouring country are still remembered. What explains the subsequent political insistence on restoring an arrangement that the Supreme Court has now recognised as constitutionally valid to abrogate?

And what about the Kashmiri Pandits? Thousands of Hindu families were driven out of the Valley during the tragic exodus of 1990. Successive political establishments, including the National Conference, cannot escape scrutiny over the circumstances that led to this humanitarian catastrophe. What concrete, lasting steps did the Abdullah-led governments take to ensure their dignified and secure return? Their displacement cannot be reduced to an inconvenient footnote whenever the National Conference speaks about Kashmir’s political rights.

The party must also answer for the long-standing controversies surrounding governance, financial accountability and the administration of the Jammu and Kashmir Cricket Association. Public institutions and public funds are not the private inheritance of political families. Accountability cannot be selective.

To be fair, the Supreme Court’s December 2023 judgment upheld the abrogation of Article 370 while recording the Union government’s assurance that statehood would be restored at the earliest. Omar is entitled to demand fulfilment of that assurance. But he cannot use the legitimate statehood question as a political platform to revive the entire pre-2019 constitutional dispute without answering for his party’s record.

The contrast with Ladakh’s Union Territory administration also deserves an honest public debate, rather than selective political comparisons. Equally, the Pahalgam terror attack exposed the continuing security challenges in the region. No political leadership can treat terrorism as merely another talking point in its confrontation with New Delhi.

Omar Abdullah should stop confusing political entitlement with public accountability. Statehood is one constitutional question; the National Conference’s political history, its position on Article 370, its approach towards Pakistan and its record on Kashmiri Pandits are entirely different questions.

Before demanding unquestioning trust from the Centre, the Abdullah family must demonstrate that it has learnt from history. The people of Jammu and Kashmir deserve accountable governance, security, dignity and equal constitutional rights. They do not deserve another round of political ambiguity dressed up as a struggle for regional pride.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *