Poorna Pranjya (continued)
This is an article series. Please read all previous articles before reading this article. The URLs for all previous articles are located in the SPECIAL THOUGHTS section.
Let’s continue to ponder over the third Avataara of Shree Mukhya Praana Devata, namely Poorna Prajnya.
Earlier, we had learnt that when Bheema Sena went to fetch Saugandhikaa Pushpa, he ended up slaying billions of Asura-s in Gandha Maadana Parvata. One of them was Manimanta, the leader of Krodha Vasha Gana of Asura-s. Manimanta vowed to return to earth as a Braahmana, learn the Veda-s with an intention to mess up their very essence & purpose and render it useless for those who seek Yathaartha Jnyaana (factual & resourceful knowledge about the creator and his creation) and Moksha (deliverance from the cycle of birth/death). Cutting a long story short… eventually, Manimanta succeeded in taking birth as the son of a widowed Brahmana woman and somehow learnt the Veda-s too… and deliberately interpreted them maliciously. How?!
Well… very early in this series, we learnt that the most concise and precise way of summarizing Hinduism is as stated by Shree Krishna in Bhagavad Geeta, Chapter 15, Verses 15, 16, 17 & 18. Let’s recall the first of these 4 verses (Chapter 15, Verse 15):
sarvasya chaaham hrudi sannivishto
matta: smruti: jnyaanam apohanam cha |
vedai: cha sarvai: aham eva vedyo
vedaanta krut vedavit eva chaaham ||15||
Meaning: [Shree Krishna says] “I am firmly situated at the core of everything. Factual & resourceful knowledge, remembering and forgetting do happen through me. I am the one who is experienceable through the entirety of Veda-s. I am the one who authored/compiled Vedaanta (Veda Sootra-s a.k.a Brahma Sootra-s which captures the quintessence of Vedic knowledge). And, I am the one who has experienced the innermost essence of the Veda-s”. This is exactly what Manimanta attacked, abused, maliciously interpreted and distorted.
Firstly, Manimanta maliciously interpreted the term “Vedaanta” very literally as the end part of Veda-s (Anta means “end”). This was like planting a malicious seed to initiate the process of distorting the sanctity of the Veda-s.
Next, you may recall from earlier explanation in this series that Veda-s have 4 parts: Samhitaa, Braahmana, Aaranyaka and Upanishat. These 4 parts are not mentioned in any sequential or chronological or any other particular order. But Manimanta maliciously interpreted these 4 parts to be sequential… and with that, he maliciously interpreted the term “Vedaanta” to be referring to only the Upanishat-s. The malicious seed planted earlier was now sprouting.
Going further along the aforesaid malicious interpretations, Manimanta introduced the term “Atattva Vedaka”. But he never explained what it meant. Instead, he would bluff and retort with questions like: “Don’t you know what it means?” or “You never heard this term at all? And you call yourself a scholar?” or “This is a very basic term. This is the first term one should know while starting Vedic studies” and so on… but he never gave a straight answer to explain the term he coined. This bluffing and gaslighting technique seems to have worked quite easily with most who hadn’t studied the Veda-s in depth… because, when he told them something no one had ever heard before, they just assumed that he knew better or perhaps even better than the best of all scholars at that time. This bluffing seems to have worked with the scholars of that time too because, going by basic human psychology, nobody wants to be embarrassed in public being told that they had heard a certain term which Manimanta claimed to be the very basic, especially when it has the potential to negatively affect their source of income and livelihood. Thus, the malicious seed that had sprouted was beginning to grow as a creeper and creep its way into every home.
At the time when Manimanta took his Avataara, the socio-political state of affairs at that time was such that Buddhism had taken over the entire landscape stretching from Gandhaara (today’s Afghanistan) in the west to far east and to Simhala (today’s Srilanka). Buddhism completely rejects the Veda-s and their authenticity. Though there were many different sub denominations under Buddhism, one particular sub denomination, referred to as “Maadhyamika” school of thought, is specifically completely atheistic. Over time, Buddhists had become so intolerant that they systematically persecuted the followers of Vedic philosophy. Therefore, the Vedic scholars had pretty much nowhere to go where they would feel protected. Under these circumstances, someone… just about anyone… who could debate with the Buddhists and win meant a huge relief to the followers of the Vedic way of life. Manimanta took full advantage of this situation. While the Buddhists had already converted large population of Vedic followers to Buddhism, bluffing with hitherto unheard terms such as “Atattva Vedaka” was destroying the Vedic philosophy from within. Manimanta’s hypothesis had started to cause tremendous damage to the basic reputation of the Veda-s which were hitherto known as the most sacred and flawless source of knowledge about the Creator and his Creation.
Yet some brave scholars risked their everything, including their very lives, and bravely questioned Manimanta’s bluff. They argued that the word “Tatva” means fact… that it is quite obvious that the word “Atattva” is just an antonym of the word “Tatva”… and that it just means “non-factual”. Therefore, they argued that the term “Atattva Vedaka” can only mean “something that does not reveal facts”, which is just a convoluted way of saying “It’s a Lie”. The brave scholars argued that Manimanta had only invented a new term in Sanskrit for the word “Lie” and that he was only saying, in a convoluted way, that the Vedaas were a lie. But Manimanta’s hypothesis had already become quite popular. Common people follow what is popular rather than make an effort to use reason and follow only that which makes sense. Thus, Manimanta had already caused great damage.
Though Manimanta never explained what “Atattva Vedaka” really meant, perhaps upon some inquiry by his newfound followers, he did elaborate on which part of the Veda-s he considered to be “Atattva Vedaka”. This should clearly show Manimanta’s malicious intent. As mentioned earlier, Veda-s have 4 parts: Samhitaa, Braahmana, Aaranyaka and Upanishat. Also as mentioned earlier, Manimanta maliciously interpreted that Vedaanta is something drawn from the “End part of the Veda-s” and that the end part of the Veda-s is the Upanishat. So, right up front… Manimanta had discarded Samhitaa, Braahmana and Aaranyaka as “Atattva Vedaka”. In other words, by the very malicious interpretation of the term “Vedaanta” as the end part of the Veda-s, Manimanta had already called 75% of the Veda-s as “Lies”.
How about the Upanishat-s? Well, Manimanta introduced another term that nobody had heard until then, namely “Mahaa Vaakya-s”. The word “Vaakya” means “Sentence”, and “Mahaa Vaakya” means “Great Sentence”. Anyone who knows any language understands what a sentence looks like. But very maliciously, Manimanta picked 4 phrase fragments that seemed to support his fallacious hypothesis – one each from an Upanishat in each of the 4 Veda-s – and called them “Mahaa Vaakya-s” (Great Sentences) when they were actually not even full sentences. Here are those so-called “Mahaa Vaakya-s” (Great Sentences).
- prajnyaanam brahma – a phrase fragment from Aitareya Upanishat (part of Rig Veda)
- aham brahmaasmi – a phrase fragment from Bruhad Aaranyaka Upanishat (part of Yajur Veda)
- tattvamasi – a phrase fragment from Chaandogya Upanishat (part of Saama Veda)
- ayam aatmaa brahma – a phrase fragment from Maandookya Upanishat (part of Atharva Veda)
Observe how Manimanta puts the above only as “Mahaa Vaakya-s” and not really as “Tattva” or “Tattva Vedaka” or “Satya” or any such unequivocal terms which refer to Truth. According to Manimanta, the above 4 phrase fragments are the only worthy elements of the Veda-s. Everything else is “Atattva Vedaka”, or basically “Lie”. In other words, the Buddhists said it without mincing words that they do not consider the Veda-s as testimony of truth. But what Manimanta was doing is no different from the Buddhist line of thought, except he was saying it in a very maliciously convoluted way that will confuse most commoners.
You may’ve observed that the Veda-s have been described as Druma (Tree). Shree Krishna too uses this analogy in Bhagavad Geeta (Chapter 15, Verse 1). A tree grows to its full and finite height, stays firm, can withstand hard weather and yet offer shade, fruits, support for many other species when it is alive… and also when it is cut down. But, unlike a tree, a creeper can grow and grow forever. It can spread far and wide. A creeper takes support any way it can find and creeps on to walls, trees, poles, fences and just about anything. The malicious creeper of Manimanta’s fallacious hypothesis is somewhat like that. It continued to grow and, after ruining the meaning and basic intent of the Veda-s, its next target was Vedaanta (the Quintessence of Vedic Philosophy). As they say… you say one lie… and then another lie to justify the first lie… and then another, and then yet another and it goes on. Likewise, Manimanta introduced yet another fallacious term namely “Maayaa Vaada”. He urged that this entire creation is “Maayaa” and “Mithyaa”. The true meaning of the word “Maayaa” is “Mahimaa” (which means great knowledge, superiority, superlative Yogic ability). But Manimanta maliciously interpreted “Maayaa” to mean “Illusion”. Have you noticed how the Westerners refer to our Puraana-s as “Mythology”. Ever wondered why? It is because of Manimanta’s malicious interpretation of Paramaatma’s creation as “Maayaa” (illusion) and “Mithyaa” (false or Myth). In plain English, Manimanta preached that the Veda-s are “False”, Paramaatma’s creation is “False”. And, as per the maliciously interpreted “Mahaa Vaakya-s” mentioned above, Paramaatma’s creation is also “False”. So, basically Paramaatma, Jeevaatma, Jada, the Veda-s, this entire universe… everything was “False” according to Manimanta.
If you are wondering, how Manimanta managed to maliciously interpret Paramaatma’s creation as “Mithyaa” (False), then here is how!!! Manimanta maliciously interpreted the so-called “Mahaa Vaakya” namely “aham brahma asmi” to mean “Aatma itself is Brahma”. So, if Aatma itself is Brahma, and if it is Brahma who created the Universe and not the Aatma… then this Universe is an illusion. Did you get it? I didn’t either. That sounds grossly illogical to me.
Manimanta moved on to his next lie. The Aatma, which he maliciously interpreted as Brahma, created this universe, but soon after… the Aatma acquired Ajnyaana (the opposite of correct, resourceful knowledge)… and therefore, the Aatma forgot that it is Brahma, the creator of this universe. As you can see… it goes from one lie to the next.
Manimanta’s next target was to acquire the title of “Jagad Guru”. There are some criteria to be met for one to be recognized as a “Jagad Guru”. Listing these criteria is beyond the scope of this article. But one of the criteria is that a person must author a commentary on Bhagavad Geeta. And thus, Bhagavad Geeta became Manimanta’s next target. Here in, Manimanta seems to go on a soliloquy:
His question to himself: Who has Ajnyaana?
His answer to his own question: Why do you care?
His next question to himself: I’m asking because whoever has Ajnyaana has to try and come out of it. Correct?
His own answer to his own question: Let whoever has Ajnyaana worry about it. Why do you care?
His next question to himself: Suppose it is me who has Ajnyaana?
His own answer to his own question: Then why are you asking “Who has Ajnyaana?”
Do you see anything conclusive or useful in the above soliloquy? What kind of logic is this? That’s it!!! I’m exhausted explaining Manimanta’s fallacious hypothesis, riddled with lies. But unfortunately… over time, this malicious interpretation spread far and wide. Ultimately, it became so rampant that the correct interpretation just vanished completely from the common teaching methodology. This is the reason why Shree Mukhya Praana Devataa – who is destined to be Brahma in the future and is therefore required to be an authority on Vedic knowledge – had to take his third Avataara as Poorna Prajnya.
Popularity can be quite a dangerous thing. This applies to both being popular and also to following what is popular. Long time ago, I had read a quote in a school classroom, while watching my children participate in some event. The quote read “What’s True is seldom popular. And what’s popular is seldom True”. I urge the reader to think it over, because… to this very day, Manimanta’s hypothesis is extremely popular. This is extremely unfortunate. There may be many reasons for this. But to this day, people argue that Manimanta’s Avataara saved the Veda-s from the Buddhist persecutors, and that Manimanta used whatever technique occurred to him… but the result was that the Veda-s were saved. So, what is wrong? My question is… If someone saved the Veda-s by calling them a collection of lies, can we really call it “saving the Veda-s”? Can we really credit such an individual with saving the Veda-s?
In reality, the credit of saving the Veda-s from the Buddhist persecutors should go to Shree Kumaareela Bhatta. There are clear historical records to support this. But unfortunately, Hindus don’t seem to give Kumaareela Bhatta any credit for his efforts in saving the Veda-s like how they shower this credit over Manimanta. People also wrongly give credit to Manimanta today as the first person to author/compile Vedaanta, while fully forgetting the declaration in Bhagavad Geeta (Chapter 15, Verse 15 as mentioned earlier) that Shree Krishna himself is the author of Vedaanta… and that Shree Krishna predates Manimanta’s Avataara. A very important part of the Vedic way of life is to give credit only where it is due.
In comparison… Buddhist persecutors had also targeted Poorna Prajnya. They tried to subdue him through Tarka (arguments/debate). But Poorna Prajnya didn’t resort to calling the Veda-s a collection of lies just to save them, because he didn’t have to. Poorna Prajnya was completely honest, bold, and straightforward in laying down the facts.
How Poorna Prajnya tackled the Buddhist persecutors is very interesting. Poorna Pranya’s life history has been documented very well in his biography composed by one of his contemporaries, by name Shree Naaraayana Pandita. Skipping various details of his life history, it should suffice to say that Poorna Prajnya had a great reputation of being extremely strong physically. Therefore, the Buddhists seem to have avoided any physical clash and tried to subdue him only through Tarka (arguments/debate). As usual, the Buddhists’ Tarka would start by their complete rejection of the Veda-s as any form of acceptable proof. As a standard, they always wanted everything to be settled through Tarka (arguments/debate) without quoting any verses from the Veda-s. Poorna Prajnya’s counter argument was “How can Tarka (arguments/debate) be any form of acceptable proof when it is clearly evident that even true things can be proven wrong through Tarka (arguments/debate)? One can use Tarka only to argue. One cannot use Tarka to know the Truth about the Creator and his Creation. Truth has to be experienced… and that is what the Veda-s are. Veda-s are what the great Rushi-s personally experienced. One cannot deny someone’s personal experience through their inexperience of the same. You can evaluate how this compares with Manimanta’s argument that the Veda-s are a collection of lies. It is clearly not the same.
Poorna Prajnya laid utmost emphasis on Shree Krishna’s words in Bhagavad Geeta, Chapter 15, Verses 15-18. He has quoted these verses in several of his scriptures to support his thesis, which never goes against Bhagavad Geeta. In other words, if you accept Bhagavad Geeta, then you automatically accept Poorna Prajnya’s thesis… and on the contrary, if you accept Manimanta’s fallacious hypothesis, then you automatically reject Bhagavad Geeta.
Here’s a basic question… and hopefully a no-brainer.
Would you accept Manimanta’s fallacies and reject Bhagavad Geeta?
OR
Would you accept the Bhagavad

