Congress’s desperation to regain political relevance and win electoral mandates appears to have reached an indefensible level, with even the Bharat cricket team’s selection decisions being given a communal colour. The latest controversy over Hyderabad pacer Mohammed Siraj’s omission from the playing XI against New Zealand in the first Test at Wellington is a case in point. There is absolutely nothing wrong with questioning a selection decision. Former India captains Sunil Gavaskar and Ravi Shastri did precisely that, expressing their disappointment over leaving out an experienced fast bowler who has repeatedly delivered for the country. Even former skipper Mohammad Azharuddin questioned the decision. Such criticism is legitimate and deserves consideration. But when Congress MP Imran Masood suggests that Siraj was overlooked because of his name, asking, “His name is Siraj, isn’t that reason enough?”, it exposes the party’s disturbing inclination to inject religion into an otherwise sporting decision. This is not constructive criticism; it is an irresponsible attempt to manufacture communal suspicion without producing a shred of evidence. What makes this insinuation particularly ridiculous is that Siraj was very much part of Bharatt’s announced Test squad. He was left out of the final playing XI, not dropped from the national team. The selectors and team management opted for Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna, Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj as their four-pronged pace attack, with Washington Sundar providing the spin option. The batting coach subsequently defended the combination, explaining that the team management believed it was best suited to the conditions and New Zealand’s left-handed top order. One may disagree with that assessment, as Gavaskar and Shastri did, but converting a selection disagreement into an allegation of religious discrimination is an entirely different matter. Incidentally, Siraj had also returned to the playing XI in the final ODI against New Zealand, taking two wickets, including those of Tim Seifert and Finn Allen. His credentials are not in question; neither should his religious identity become a political weapon. This is hardly the first time Congress has attempted to introduce such a divisive narrative into Indian cricket. In October 2025, party spokesperson Shama Mohamed questioned whether Sarfaraz Khan’s exclusion from national selection was because of his surname, insinuating religious discrimination. Now, another Congress MP is making a similar insinuation about Siraj. What exactly does the party hope to achieve by repeatedly suggesting that Muslim cricketers are being discriminated against? Does it conveniently forget that Bharat has had Mohammad Azharuddin as captain, while Mohammed Shami, Mohammed Siraj and several other cricketers have represented the country with distinction? Their achievements belong to Bharatiya cricket, not to any particular religious community.

The danger of such politics is that it places an unnecessary psychological burden on the very players it claims to defend. Siraj has earned his place through hard work, discipline and performance, overcoming considerable personal and professional challenges. He does not need political patrons to establish his credentials or fight battles on the basis of his faith. Nor should he be made to feel that every selection decision involving him is a referendum on his religious identity. The same applies to Shami, who faced disgraceful religious abuse from sections of social media after Bharat’s defeat against Pakistan in the 2021 T20 World Cup. Virat Kohli rightly condemned those attacks. Sporting merit, not religion, must remain the only legitimate basis for judging a cricketer. More disturbing is the larger political mindset that seeks to divide national institutions along religious lines. The Indian Army, which stands as an embodiment of national unity, must never become another arena for such politics. In August 2024, the Defence Ministry told Parliament that all citizens, irrespective of class, creed, region or religion, were eligible for recruitment into the Army, and that the policy after Independence was not to raise new regiments for a particular community, religion or region. That principle deserves to be protected, not undermined by political demands for communal representation. A soldier’s loyalty is to the nation, just as a cricketer’s allegiance is to Team Bharat. Congress would do well to understand that repeatedly invoking minority identity does not automatically translate into political empowerment or electoral support. It can instead deepen mistrust, encourage polarisation and undermine institutions that have traditionally brought Bharatiyas together. The party’s frustration over electoral setbacks cannot justify turning every issue into a communal controversy. If it has evidence of discrimination, let it produce facts and demand an impartial inquiry. Otherwise, such allegations are nothing more than politically motivated insinuations. Azharuddin, who himself captained Bharat and knows the pressures of international cricket, should appreciate the damage that communalising selection decisions can cause. His cricketing legacy and political affiliations are separate matters; neither gives anyone the licence to cast aspersions without evidence. Bharat’s dressing room must remain a place where talent, teamwork and commitment determine a player’s worth. A cricketer must be free to pray in his own faith, but when he wears the Bharat jersey, he represents 1.4 billion Bharatiyas. The same applies to every soldier in uniform. Neither cricket nor the armed forces should be reduced to religious arithmetic. Congress must stop treating national institutions as electoral battlegrounds. Dividing Bharatiyas may serve a short-term political narrative, but it damages the larger national interest. Religion is a personal faith; representing Bharat is a national honour. Neither should ever be compromised for vote-bank politics.
