The real test of religious tolerance is whether we defend every citizen’s right to practise a faith with equal conviction—and refuse to tolerate insults against any religion.
As a news buff who spends considerable time watching television debates—equal parts fascinating and exasperating—I am often struck by the contradictions displayed by political spokespersons and self-proclaimed champions of secularism. In the pursuit of political advantage, conviction frequently takes a back seat, while the defence of religious interests appears to depend less on principle than on electoral arithmetic. Apparently, in the grand marketplace of Bharatiya politics, even secularism comes with its own vote-bank pricing.
This raises an uncomfortable question: has secularism in Bharat become a commitment to equal respect for all faiths, or is it increasingly being interpreted through the convenient prism of minority appeasement and majority accommodation?
The Congress, which frequently invokes its legacy of secularism and its contribution to the freedom struggle, is not alone in facing this question. Several regional parties, too, project themselves as protectors of minority interests, particularly those of Muslims. Protecting minorities from discrimination is unquestionably a legitimate democratic responsibility. The problem begins when protection becomes selective, questions about religious institutions are portrayed as attacks on an entire community, and political expediency is dressed up as constitutional principle.
The Constitution guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to constitutional limitations. It does not require anyone to abandon personal beliefs to earn a secular certificate. Nor does it authorise political parties to treat any community as a permanent electoral constituency whose interests must remain beyond scrutiny. Democracy is not a loyalty programme in which political parties collect votes and, in return, promise immunity from uncomfortable questions.
The conduct of party spokespersons presents another intriguing contradiction. Among those defending political positions associated with minority interests are individuals bearing surnames traditionally associated with Hindu Brahmin communities, including Mishra, Trivedi, Dwivedi, Jha and Sharma. There is nothing inherently objectionable about this. A surname neither determines a person’s political allegiance nor serves as a reliable certificate of religious conviction. Every citizen is free to defend a party’s position, advocate minority rights or embrace another faith.
Yet, when television debates become exercises in defending one community’s sentiments while appearing indifferent to insults against another’s Gods and Goddesses, an uncomfortable question arises: is this conviction, political convenience or simply a case of secularism with selective hearing?
If political solidarity with Muslims is the chosen position of some Hindu leaders or supporters, they are perfectly free to embrace Islam or convert to it. The Constitution protects religious freedom; no one needs to seek permission from a television anchor or political party to change faith. But conversion is a personal choice, not a prerequisite for defending minority rights. Equally, a surname is no evidence of hypocrisy, and a person’s faith cannot be conclusively judged by arguments advanced in a television studio.
The real contradiction lies elsewhere. Why should defending another community’s rights require indifference towards one’s own religious sentiments? Why should a Hindu who objects to the denigration of Hindu beliefs risk being branded communal, while similar expressions of hurt from other religious communities may attract immediate political attention? Is secularism now an examination in which the majority must repeatedly prove its innocence while everyone else is presumed entitled to the benefit of the doubt?

That is not secularism. That is selective outrage wearing a constitutional costume.
Secularism should not mean that the majority must remain silent to demonstrate tolerance, or that minority concerns must be dismissed to establish the majority’s confidence. It should mean equal dignity for every citizen, equal protection for every community and equal accountability for every institution.
Consider recurring controversies surrounding personal laws, the administration of religious endowments and allegations of encroachment involving Wakf properties. These matters deserve examination through evidence, legislation, and due process. Legitimate questions about property, governance or accountability must not be converted into accusations against an entire religious community. Equally, demands for transparency cannot be silenced merely because a religious institution is involved. Faith may command reverence, but administration involving public rights, property and legal obligations cannot claim an automatic exemption from scrutiny.
There are Muslims who openly acknowledge that Hindu society’s internal divisions can weaken its ability to articulate common concerns. Such observations deserve consideration, not because one community should imitate another, but because democratic representation becomes more effective when citizens articulate their concerns clearly and collectively. Politicians understand arithmetic remarkably well; voters, too, should not be expected to forget it.
However, unity must not be confused with uniformity. Hindu society encompasses diverse traditions, philosophies, castes, languages and schools of thought. Its pluralism is not a weakness to be eliminated. Nor should every Hindu be expected to endorse one political position or defend every practice merely because it is associated with the faith. The beauty of Hinduism lies precisely in its pluralistic traditions, tolerance and understanding of dharma. Treating these virtues as weaknesses is unfortunate; allowing them to be exploited as political vulnerabilities would be worse.
The more pressing issue is mutual respect. Criticism of religious beliefs, whether Hinduism, Islam or Christianity, is not automatically equivalent to hatred. In a democracy, ideas and institutions can be questioned. But deliberate provocation, abusive stereotyping and gratuitous ridicule of sacred figures deserve condemnation, regardless of the religion involved. Freedom of expression is not a licence for selective civility, just as religious sensitivity cannot become a veto over legitimate criticism.
Those who defend minority rights should be equally willing to defend the rights of the majority. Those who speak for Hindu interests must extend the same dignity to minorities. And those who claim secular credentials must demonstrate that their principles survive beyond election campaigns, television sound bites and the next round of vote-bank calculations. Otherwise, secularism becomes less a constitutional conviction than a campaign slogan that expires after polling day.
Bharat’s strength lies in its constitutional promise that citizens need not surrender their religious identities to belong to the nation. Genuine secularism does not demand that Hindus become less Hindu, Muslims less Muslim or Christians less Christian. It demands that all become more committed to constitutional values and more respectful of one another.
The question, therefore, is not why some Hindus defend other faiths. That is their democratic right and can be a commendable expression of solidarity. Nor should anyone’s faith be judged by a surname or political affiliation. The real question is why anyone should have to choose between respecting another person’s religion and expecting the same respect for their own.
Secularism cannot survive as a one-way obligation. It must be a shared principle: equal rights, equal accountability and equal respect for every faith. Anything less is not secularism. It is political convenience masquerading as constitutional morality.
