Right Squad, Wrong XI? Hyderabad’s Syed Mushtaq Ali Campaign So Far – A Match Analysis

OrangeNews9

Special Correspondent

One win from three. A squad good enough to go deep. And the simplest fix of all is hiding in plain sight.

In the Ranji Trophy, Abhirath Reddy opens the batting for Hyderabad. In the TG20 and the leagues, he opens. In this Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy, he does not. That one decision sums up Hyderabad’s campaign so far: the right players are in the squad, but not always in the right places.

Three matches into the tournament in Kolkata, Hyderabad have one win and two defeats — a heavy loss to Mumbai, a last-ball escape against Chhattisgarh and a narrow defeat to Vidarbha. With Goa next, there is still time to turn it around. But the corrections have to start now.

A squad worth backing

Credit first to the selectors. The squad they picked is well balanced, with experience at the top in Tanmay Agarwal, Abhirath Reddy and K Himateja, genuine all-rounders, and a bowling group led by captain CV Milind. Every role a T20 side needs is covered. The problem is not the squad. It is the eleven picked from it, the batting order built around it, and the bowling plans used on the field.

The bright spots

K Himateja has been Hyderabad’s most consistent batter, scoring 25, 37 and 41 — all at a brisk pace. Abhirath Reddy has looked in fine touch with 35 and 34 in the first two games, despite being shuffled around. Tanmay Agarwal showed against Vidarbha what the top order can do when it fires, smashing 49 off 24 balls.

With the ball, Ajay Dev Goud has been the stand-out. His 4/28 won the Chhattisgarh match and earned him the Player of the Match award, and he then helped finish the chase with the bat. Captain CV Milind has been a true all-rounder: a wicket with the very first ball against Chhattisgarh on his way to 3/20, and a quick 22 off 12 balls against Mumbai. Rakshann Readdi has taken wickets in the last two games and kept his nerve in the last-wicket stand that sealed the win. Rahul Buddhi and Tanay Thyagarajan did the rescue job when the Chhattisgarh chase wobbled.

So the raw material is clearly there. Runs at the top, wickets up front, fight in the lower order. The question is not whether Hyderabad have the players. It is how those players are being used.

OrangeNews9

Where it has gone wrong

Six decisions stand out. Look closely, and most of them are linked — one change in the batting led to another in the bowling, and the team has been chasing its own tail since.

  1. The best batting line-up hasn’t played. This is the biggest issue. Abhirath Reddy has been one of Hyderabad’s most successful openers across the TG20, the leagues and the Ranji Trophy. Only last month, he and Tanmay Agarwal put on a century opening stand against Andhra.

His TG20 record makes the case on its own. Opening the batting and captaining Hyderabad E-Champions to the inaugural title, he finished as the tournament’s highest run-scorer with 549 runs in 10 innings, at an average of 61.00 and a strike rate of 201.84. That included a century (101 not out) and four fifties, and he topped the charts for both fours (58) and sixes (33). He was named Player of the Tournament and won the Orange Cap. In Qualifier 2, he and his opening partner put on 124 in 12.3 overs to settle the game early.

Yet in this tournament he batted at No. 3 against Mumbai and has been moved up and down the order since. In his first two innings here, he made 35 off 24 and 34 off 26 — 69 runs off 50 balls, a strike rate of 138. Those are useful knocks, but well short of the 200-plus tempo he sets when he opens. In a short format where rhythm is everything, a proven opener should open. Abhirath and Tanmay at the top, with Himateja to follow, is the obvious combination — and not using it has hurt the team.

Put simply: when your Orange Cap winner and Player of the Tournament is an opener, you open with him.

Aman Rao’s versatility makes this easier. He is a dangerous batter at the top, but he is just as comfortable further down the order, as he showed for Warangal Warriors against Ranga Reddy Risers in the TG20. That flexibility is an asset: Hyderabad can open with Abhirath and Tanmay and still have Aman Rao’s firepower in the middle.

  1. Good selection, but not the best playing eleven. A good squad only becomes a good team when the right eleven take the field. So far, the combinations picked have not made the best use of what is available. Picking a squad is about choosing the players; picking an eleven is about choosing the plan for the day. Right now, the plan and the players are not matching.
  2. An extra batter, but no extra speed. After the first match, a bowler made way for an extra batter. The idea was presumably to bat deeper and score faster. It did not work. Against Chhattisgarh, with the extra batter in, Hyderabad slumped to 129 for 7 chasing 169 and needed the last pair to get home off the final ball. The scoring rate did not go up, and the attack lost an option.
  3. The all-rounders already give us depth. The extra batter was never really needed. Hyderabad have genuine all-rounders in Milind, Tanay Thyagarajan and Pranav Varma, and bowlers like Ajay Dev Goud and Rakshann Readdi who can hold a bat. Against Chhattisgarh, it was the lower order that won the match. With that kind of depth, picking a batter in place of a bowler weakens the attack without adding much.
  4. A young bowler was handled wrongly. Giving a young bowler his chance is a good thing. But handing him a game against a Mumbai side with Suryakumar Yadav and Shivam Dube, and then dropping him straight after, is unfair to the player and tells us nothing about his real ability. He would have been better brought in a little later, against suitable opposition, and given a proper run.m.
  5. Bowling choices could have been sharper. In both defeats, the opposition scored at will. Mumbai chased 173 in just 13.1 overs, with 41 balls to spare. Vidarbha chased 196, with captain Atharva Taide hitting 82 off 45 balls. Questions need to be asked about who bowled when, especially in the powerplay and at the death, and how the match-ups were planned. With one bowler fewer in the eleven, the captain also had less room to change things when the plan was not working.

The way forward

The fixes are not complicated. Put Abhirath Reddy back at the top with Tanmay Agarwal. Trust the all-rounders and go back to a full bowling attack. Give young players a fair run in the right matches. Plan the bowling around match-ups, not habit, and tighten up in the field.

Against Goa, that means Abhirath and Tanmay opening, Himateja to follow, and the full attack back — Milind, Ajay Dev Goud and Rakshann Readdi, supported by the all-rounders Tanay Thyagarajan and Pranav Varma.

The selectors have given Hyderabad a squad good enough to go deep in this tournament. Now the best eleven has to take the field — and the best opener has to open.

Goa is the next test. The answers are already in the dressing room.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *