Destructive, foreign-funded cowboys are not Gen Z; they are merely scriptwriters of disruption
By K.S. Nagarajan
It is unfortunate that an entire generation, particularly Gen Z, is sometimes unfairly branded because of the destructive conduct of a handful of disruptive elements. Those who indulge in organised disruption, provoke unrest or pursue vested interests cannot be passed off as representatives of an entire generation. Calling them Gen Z is an insult to the millions of young people who are educated, ambitious, scientifically inclined and genuinely concerned about the future of the country. Such elements are better described as scriptwriters of chaos than representatives of a generation. The real debate, however, must move beyond labels and address a much larger institutional question: why should citizens continue to suffer interminable judicial delays when alternative mechanisms such as arbitration can deliver quicker and more effective dispute resolution?
Are space scientists, DRDO scientists and medical professionals any less learned because they address one another as colleagues rather than constantly using expressions such as ‘learned friend’? The legal fraternity has developed its own conventions, wherein advocates appearing for petitioners and respondents contest interpretations of the same law. One may seek to twist the letter of a provision to suit an argument, while another attempts to establish its true spirit and intent. But does the ability to manipulate legal technicalities necessarily make someone learned? Shouldn’t the ultimate objective of the justice delivery system be to discover the truth, uphold the spirit of the law and ensure that justice is delivered without unnecessary delay? The distinction between interpreting the law and exploiting its technicalities must never be lost.
This brings us to the pressing need to encourage arbitration as a mainstream mechanism for resolving disputes. Why should judges personally shoulder the burden of every pending case when experienced senior advocates and retired judges can be entrusted with arbitration responsibilities? The former Chief Justice of India has also spoken about the importance of promoting arbitration to facilitate early settlement of disputes. A structured national arbitration mechanism, with appropriate safeguards, could substantially reduce the burden on conventional courts. A committee comprising the Prime Minister, Union Law Minister, Attorney General of India, a representative of the Bar Council of India and a retired Supreme Court judge could oversee the framework, without involving any sitting judge in its administration. Such a body must function transparently, with clear eligibility criteria, independence and safeguards against political interference.
It is rather contradictory that the increasing number of pending cases is repeatedly cited as justification for increasing the number of judges, while comparatively little attention is given to the possibility of delegating suitable disputes to qualified arbitrators. If senior advocates and retired judges are empowered to resolve appropriate civil, commercial and contractual disputes through time-bound arbitration, the pressure on regular courts could decline considerably. The prospect of an early decision would also discourage frivolous litigation and those who use prolonged court proceedings as a strategy to harass opponents or evade accountability. Arbitration, of course, cannot replace judicial adjudication in constitutional matters, criminal prosecutions or disputes requiring the exercise of sovereign judicial powers. Nor should it compromise the litigants’ right to a fair hearing or appropriate judicial review.
There is another uncomfortable reality that cannot be ignored: the Government is among the largest litigants in the country. A considerable number of disputes arise because public officials either fail to interpret rules correctly, act negligently or, in some instances, take decisions that subsequently invite legal challenges. The result is a prolonged battle at public expense, with taxpayers ultimately bearing the cost. A mechanism for early dispute resolution, coupled with accountability for officials who unnecessarily drag the Government into litigation, could save enormous public resources. Arbitration should not become another bureaucratic exercise but an instrument of genuine institutional reform.
An innovative panel of independent arbitrators, drawn from senior advocates and retired judges, could be considered for suitable cases. Arbitrators could be selected through a transparent, randomised allocation system, subject to conflict-of-interest checks and the consent of the parties. The objective must be to ensure neutrality, prevent forum-shopping and eliminate the possibility of vested interests influencing the outcome.
Finally, judicial accountability deserves a meaningful debate. Constitutional institutions must function with transparency and accountability, while preserving their independence. The judiciary cannot be exempt from constructive institutional scrutiny merely because it occupies a constitutional position. A carefully designed mechanism involving appropriate constitutional authorities, retired judges and representatives of the Bar could examine systemic concerns, without interfering with judicial independence or reviewing individual judgments outside established legal procedures.
The point is simple: justice delayed is justice denied. Increasing the number of judges alone cannot be the permanent answer. India needs a judicial system that is faster, more accessible, transparent and accountable. Encouraging arbitration, reducing unnecessary litigation and ensuring institutional responsibility would be important steps in that direction. Gen Z deserves a better future, and that future must include a justice delivery system that does not make citizens wait for years to obtain what is rightfully theirs.
