HCA Ka King Kaun?

HCA-HC

Barred clubs return as SGM signatories, familiar names resurface, and the Apex Council faces uncomfortable questions. Has HCA’s judicial clean-up been reduced to an exercise in futility?

Special Correspondent

The Hyderabad Cricket Association (HCA) appears to be witnessing yet another attempt by familiar power centres to regain control of its affairs, raising serious questions about the fate of the judicially mandated clean-up. Three years after former Supreme Court judge Justice L. Nageswara Rao exposed how a handful of individuals and their families allegedly controlled the association through multiple clubs; the very network identified in his findings appears to be resurfacing.

The most glaring contradiction concerns the 57 clubs barred from attending the adjourned AGM on July 19, 2025. The Apex Council minutes dated July 18 explicitly recorded: “As per the legal opinion, 57 disqualified clubs were not permitted to attend.” The minutes were signed by Acting President Sardar Daljeet Singh, Joint Secretary T. Basava Raju and Councillor Sunil Kumar Agarwal. Yet, eleven months later, the same three names appeared on a letter seeking a Special General Meeting (SGM), alongside representatives of 32 of those very 57 clubs.

Had the disqualification of these clubs been withdrawn? Had their membership status changed through a recognised legal process? If not, on what authority were their signatures being entertained for a meeting that could potentially alter HCA’s bye-laws? The apparent double standard is difficult to ignore. When their participation was considered legally impermissible in 2025, they were kept out. When their signatures became useful in 2026, they were suddenly back in the picture.

The Apex Council members who signed both sets of documents owe the cricketing fraternity an explanation. They cannot selectively invoke legal opinion to exclude clubs on one occasion and conveniently overlook the same restrictions when their support is required. Equally, the club secretaries cannot claim to be champions of democratic governance while remaining silent about the legitimacy of their own participation.

Is this about cricket administration or the preservation of electoral influence? Justice L. Nageswara Rao’s findings in 2023 make the latest developments even more disturbing. Appointed by the Supreme Court to clean up HCA, he recorded that 80 clubs were owned by 12 individuals and their families, describing the arrangement as a coterie controlling elections to key Apex Council positions. He warned that a handful of people controlling multiple clubs could form a cartel and decide who should be elected.

HCA- Home

His report also flagged payments exceeding a crore of rupees to club secretaries under the guise of assignments, substantial medical expenditure for club office-bearers from HCA funds and attempts to bypass tenure restrictions, resulting in unchecked power, lobbying and corruption. The Supreme Court described his recommendations as “prima facie salutary”. Yet, on our examination of the handwritten SGM signatory list against Justice Nageswara Rao’s findings, more than ten individuals identified in connection with multiple-club control appear to have signed the latest request. Several have signed on behalf of clubs that were barred.

These overlaps warrant verification and explanation. They cannot simply be dismissed as coincidences. Individuals are entitled to associate with one another, but using multiple clubs to perpetuate electoral influence is precisely the structural problem that the judicial intervention sought to address. Have the club secretaries learnt anything from the findings, or have they merely perfected the art of changing alliances while retaining their influence? And what about the Apex Council? Its members cannot plead ignorance of the judicial findings. If the same individuals, clubs and electoral networks continue to dominate HCA, what exactly has the reform exercise achieved? The latest SGM initiative raises further questions.

The request asks members to discuss and pass amendments to the bye-laws without spelling out the actual amendments. How can club representatives endorse changes they have not even seen? Are they being asked to sign a blank cheque? The prescribed procedure for convening an SGM, including the required notice to the Secretary and the applicable 30-day period, also needs to be examined.

Why was the established procedure not followed before approaching the High Court? More importantly, what is the real agenda behind these proposed amendments? Justice Nageswara Rao’s recommendations, submitted to the Registrar of Societies on February 14, 2024, in a 162-sheet filing described as an amendment, already provide a roadmap for reform.

They include transparent rules for admitting and removing member clubs and age and tenure restrictions for club office-bearers in conformity with the nine-year Lodha reform principle. Are these recommendations part of the proposed SGM amendments? If so, why have they not been disclosed? If not, whose interests are these changes intended to serve? Any attempt to dilute or circumvent the judicial recommendations would amount to reversing the very reforms HCA desperately needs. The Apex Council members supporting or facilitating this initiative must answer these questions instead of hiding behind collective decisions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *